Last Updated on November 3, 2023
I did a LOT of eating while in Caye Caulker! I mainly tried to stick to a cheap budget. I don’t actually like seafood which make up the majority of Caye Caulker restaurants and food guides. So here are a few different options for breakfast, lunch, dinner and snacks while in Belize!
Caye Caulker Restaurants
- Caye Caulker Restaurants
Jenny’s To Go Food or Errolyn’s House of Fry Jacks
🗺Jenny’s To Go Food, Crocodile Street, Caye Caulker, Belize | Errolyn’s House of Fry Jacks, Avenida Langosta, Caye Caulker, Belize
Other than British food that I miss, I can’t pin point another food that I’ve had on my travels, that I crave as much as what I do Fry Jacks!!! Belizean Fry Jacks are deep fried dough/puffy bread that come with various fillings such as ham, egg, refried beans, cheese and chicken.
My go to was ham and egg which set me back all of $3.50BZD/$1.75USD. Honestly they are the best breakfast in Caye Caulker!
There are several different locations selling Fry Jacks, but I thought Jenny’s To Go Food or Errolyn’s House of Fry Jacks did the best ones. Errolyn’s is very popular and has a small undercover seating area too.
Ice N Beans
🗺Front Street, Caye Caulker, Belize
Ice N Beans is a little coffee shop that opens at 6am, great for the early risers! It also stays open until the early evening. They sell coffee (iced and hot), teas (the passionfruit iced tea is yummy), breads and bagels, bubble waffles and a build your own yoghurt parfait option…a slightly healthier option than Fry Jacks!
The build your own yoghurt parfait is great. First you pick a base yoghurt flavour, then one fresh fruit option, and then up to 3 items, such as nuts or honey.
It is a slightly more expensive Caye Caulker breakfast option compared to Fry Jacks. Menu food items cost roughly between $8 – $10BZD. Out the back of coffee shop they have picnic beaches and seating on the beach, with great sea views.
Sweet Treats & Snacks
Of course one of the best things to do on Caye Caulker is eat ice cream! I tried out 3 different ice cream shops while on the island:
- The Creamery – Actually has air conditioning which is rare as most restaurants and bars are open air…even my accommodation had no air con! I used to go in because the lady had the UK Radio 1 on (as a Brit living in the USA, I was like a moth to the flame!).
- Gelato Italiano Anna & Armando – I prefer gelato to ice cream and I loved the gelato from here but I literally had to inhale it because it melted so fast! This place is located at The Split, you can’t miss it, there’s a ice cream wave mural on the side of the building!
- Scoop D’s – Try the handmade Belizian Fudge!
Just Say The Word Baby!!! – I’m not sure what his official name is so we’ll call him ‘Just Say The Word Baby’! It’s a VERY happy, upbeat guy on a bike, he wears a big white chefs hat and apron and sells homemade cakes.
He peddles around the island shouting out ‘Just say the word baby!!!’, if you say the word, he stops! He often had a couple of different choices, 2 treats cost $5BZD/$2.50USD. I liked the coconut tarts.
Caye Caulker Bakery (🗺Avenida Langosta, Belize) – The Caye Caulker Bakery is popular with the locals and for good reason. It opens for a few hours in the morning and then again for a few in the afternoon. They have fresh homemade bread and cakes. The closer to opening time you get there, the more choice you have, once things have gone, they’re gone! I bought a large rock bun for $1.25BZD/$0.63USD!
Lunch & Dinner
Chef Juan’s Kitchen & pastries
🗺64 Crocodile Street, Caye Caulker, Belize
My accommodation recommended Chef Juan’s as their favourite Caye Caulker restaurant and it didn’t disappoint! A family in front of me asked the chef’s son what his favourite dish was, he said the coconut chicken curry which cost $18BZD/$9USD and came with rice and a side salad. I’m not great with spice but it was perfect!
He also has a selection of homemade pastries and cakes! Seating is outside only with no cover.
Lazy Lizard Bar & Grill
🗺Front Street, The Split, Caye Caulker, Belize
A popular place to hang out on Caye Caulker is The Split. When you’re here you can’t miss the 2 storey Lazy Lizard Bar & Grill. Of course they have an extensive drinks menu, with cocktails, beers, spirits and more.
But they also have a food menu. Seafood dishes takes up a large part of the menu, dinner time specials and the catch of the day. They also have salads, burgers and burritos. Meals are upwards of $20BZD, right up to $55BZD.
Around lunch and dinner time, several pop up barbecues appear along Front Street. You can get things like jerk chicken, rice and beans for $12BZD/$6USD.
Northside Beach Club
For a change of scenery, you can head over to Caye Caulker’s north island. This is home of the Northside Beach Club. They have a shuttle that connects the two islands. It’s a boutique a hotel but they also have a restaurant with a lunch menu.
Dishes cost between $22 to $35BZD and include things like salads, tacos, burgers and fish fingers.
After some food, there’s plenty of space to relax on the beach. There’s a range of sun loungers and hammocks that are free to use. As well as swim rings and an in-water volleyball net.
Non Alcoholic Coconuts & Juices
You’re in the Caribbean so of course you have to have a coconut! These are $5BZD/$2.50USD. They often lacked change for higher denomination notes (even $10USD notes!) so make sure you have small change for these vendors!
Sea Choice Juice Bar (🗺Pasero Street, Caye Caulker, Belize) – Sea Choice Juice Bar is located right next door to Errolyn’s House of Fry Jacks, so it’s a great choice for a breakfast drink! (It’s also cheaper than some of the vendors on Front Street).
One litre of freshly squeezed juice costs $5BZD/$2.50USD. Putting this into perspective, a 1 litre bottle of water is $2USD. There are several flavours to choose from, including mixed smoothie style ones (without the ice).
For the best beach bars in Caye Caulker, I have a guide here: 🍹Belize: 3 Best Bars in Caye Caulker That You Should Visit!
Other Belize Posts You May Enjoy
- 🏖️9 Awesome Things To Do In Caye Caulker, Belize!
- 📅Belize Itinerary: Belize 7 Day Itinerary For Caye Caulker & Belize City
- “Butts Up! Nuts Up!” | What To Expect Cave Tubing in Belize
- 🌴12 Tips & Things to Know When Visiting Belize in Summer (June)!
About the Author – Kylie
My travels have taken me to over 40 countries worldwide (& I lived in USA for 4yrs). I hold a BTEC National Diploma in Travel & Tourism (triple distinction) and have been writing on Between England & Everywhere since 2015.
Expert in: Adventure travel🎢, beach destinations🏖️, and packing light (mid-budget backpacker)🎒